At least one additive — a preservative called propionate — could be linked to diabetes and obesity.
Scientists are giving food additives and other ingredients more scrutiny these days, thanks to new technology that allows them to get an up-close view of how individual molecules affect the body. And they are already discovering some surprising information that could change what you put on your plate in the future.
Consider propionate, or propionic acid, a naturally oc-curring fatty acid and a common preservative found in everything from bread and animal feeds to pudding and cheese. A study published online April 24 by Science Translational Medicine found that this ingredient may disrupt the metabolism, triggering the body to produce excess glucose (blood sugar), which could lead to diabetes and obesity.
The study also raises a larger question, says one of the study’s authors, Dr. Gökhan S. Hotamlgil, the James Stevens Simmons Professor of Genetics and Metabolism and director of the Sabri Ülker Center for Metabolic Research at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health: should other individual nutrient molecules in foods —not just additives — get a closer look as well?
Fast facts about propionate
What it is: Propionate, or propionic acid, is a commonly used food preservative. Propionate isn’t foreign to the human body. It exists naturally in the gut, and some studies have even shown that it may be beneficial, says Dr. Gökhan S. Hotamlgil, director of the Sabri Ülker Center for Metabolic Research at Harvard. It’s unclear why, or if, propionate produces a different response when it occurs naturally compared with when it is consumed as a food additive.
How it’s used: Manufacturers add propionate to many different products, including bread, animal feed, frosting, pudding, jams and jellies, and cheese, to prevent the growth of mold. The FDA currently considers it safe to use as a food additive.
How to find it: It often appears on food labels as calcium propionate.
What’s new: This study found that propionate, when eaten as part of the diet, might boost the body’s production of blood sugar, which could increase the risk of diabetes and obesity.
What’s next: More study is needed to confirm these findings.
What’s in the food you’re eating?
“There are thousands of unique molecules present in our daily diets, and this study teaches us that it may be prudent to look at these ingredients more carefully,” says Dr. Hotamlgil. The long-term metabolic effects of many of these chemicals are largely unknown, even though people are already eating them on a regular basis. Even a simple molecule can produce dramatic effects inside the body, he says.
Studying the body’s response
Dr. Hotamlgil says he and his team came to study propionate because of their interest in another fatty protein that interacts with lipids, called fatty acid–binding protein 4 (FABP4). FABP4 plays a role in glucose production in the body. When the scientists gave propionate to mice, it triggered a metabolic chain reaction. First, it appeared to set off a nervous system response, which then prompted a rise in blood levels of FABP4 and a critical hormone called glucagon.
FABP4 and glucagon have an important job in the body, which is essentially the opposite of insulin’s role. Your body makes insulin to bring down high glucose levels in the blood. FABP4 and glucagon spur your liver to produce more glucose when your blood level drops. A very low blood glucose level (hypoglycemia) can be life-threatening.
But in the mouse experiment, propionate kicked FABP4 and glucagon into action while glucose levels were still in the normal range. The mice’s bodies produced more glucose in response to the propionate when it wasn’t needed. This boosted blood sugar levels higher than they should have been, a condition called hyperglycemia, which is similar to what occurs when people have diabetes.
When the mice were given propionate over time, they not only gained a weight, but also started to experience insulin resistance, a condition in which the body’s cells have trouble responding properly to insulin and absorbing glucose from the bloodstream.
“The other interesting thing is that this relationship was totally dependent on the production of FABP4 and glucagon. When those were blocked, propionic acid didn’t produce the same response,” says Dr. Hotamlgil.
Do the findings apply to people?
This finding raised another question: does propionate only affect mice, or would the same response occur in people too? Researchers tested 14 healthy people, giving half of them 1 gram of propionate and the other half a placebo. They chose that amount because it is similar to what people would normally eat in food. They took a blood sample from the recruits before they ate, 15 minutes after they ate, and then every 30 minutes for the next four hours.
Like the mice, the people who consumed propionate had the same hormone surge shortly after they ate, which indicated that humans may very well experience the same worrisome metabolic effects as the mice did. “But the study was very small, so we can’t make strong claims,” says Dr. Hotamlgil. Still, it illustrates the need to study propionate further, he says.
An upward trend in obesity
This study isn’t the only indication that propionate may be a problem. “I think the interesting thing is that the use of propionic acid has increased over time, quite dramatically. It actually does overlap with the time where there was a great rise in obesity and metabolic disease,” says Dr. Hotamlgil. This increase in diabetes and obesity has occurred over roughly the past 50 years, and some scientists have suspected that something in the environment or in the diet may be helping to drive the increase. And those numbers are still going up. Some 400 million people around the world already have diabetes, and that number is expected to increase by 40% in the next two decades, according to the study’s authors.
“We aren’t claiming that we have now explained this phenomenon,” says Dr. Hotamlgil. To determine whether propionate has played a role in that rise, researchers will need to conduct a more comprehensive human study with a greater number of subjects and longer durations of exposure, he says.
Should you change your diet?
Until scientists uncover more answers, it’s too soon to make recommendations that people avoid propionate or that the preservative be removed from the food supply. “But it strongly suggests that this, as well as many other ingredients, should be on our radar. If larger and longer human study supports the findings, it would be a very simple intervention,” says Dr. Hotamlgil. There are numerous food preservatives that could be used instead of propionate, so switching it out would be relatively easy.
In the future, Dr. Hotamlgil says his team plans to study more food ingredients, not just additives, to better understand how they interact with the human body on a biological level to influence health.
Image: © sanjeri/Getty Images
Subscribe to Harvard Health Online for immediate access to health news and information from Harvard Medical School.
As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review on all articles. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.